When I heard the news of the death of Diane Keaton at the age of 79, I felt a certain numb disbelief. I found myself questioning why I was so moved by the news. After all, we must all die and being a celebrity does not make an ounce of difference to this eventuality. Also, she was in her eightieth year and the average life expectancy for women in USA is 79.3 – 81.1 years depending on the data source. So, numerically speaking her death should not have come as a shock. Although I had never met her, she had influenced my life from a distance through screen performances and media interviews. Earlier this year, I watched ‘Baby Boom’ and who could not be touched by her quirky humour?

Perhaps her best legacy will be that she exemplified not just how to act but more importantly how to live. Whenever we caught glimpses of her on camera, she was smiling and making fun of herself with silly faces and hilarious gesticulations.

It is less a testimony to the power of the media than it is to the power of her contagious personality, that we felt we knew her. Would we feel the same if our neighbour died? For many of us the answer might be NO because we might hardly know our neighbours or have never met them. Most of us would never have met Diane but we felt as if we knew her nonetheless, in part because of her accessibility in giving many interviews over the years and her transparency – she never shirked from being honest about her feelings and experiences.

There will be no personal invite to the funeral. Is it possible to grieve from a distance? Grief should be a shared experience amongst those who knew the deceased. We are left with a modern conundrum. How can you grieve someone whom you only knew in your head but never experientially?

From the seventies, she captivated us with her film performances – from her Woody Allen days to First Wives Club and ‘Ruth and Alex’. There was something about her self-deprecating wit and emotional vulnerability as well as quirky imperfections. We could all relate to her on some level. She was the ‘every woman’ equivalent of James Stewart.

Why was Diane was so well loved and respected? If you watch any of her interviews which have suddenly proliferated around the internet, you will see that she constantly made fun of herself and was bemused by her success. Although eventually she reached the status of ‘Hollywood royalty’ mainly due to her career longevity which broached 50 years and the wise selection of the parts she played. She never strayed too far from what the audience expected from her and for which she was so enamoured. But she never assumed any airs or graces; she was as down to earth as a celebrity could be, and treated people as equals knowing full well that star status is just an illusion.

With Val Kilmer or Gene Hackman who also died this year, it was easy to reassure yourself that you could always watch one of their films and that they would forever be preserved in celluloid. With Keaton, it’s different, her body of work cannot provide the necessary comfort for a world desperately in need of the laughter and positivity she exuded. The May Angelou quote is refreshingly apropos– “people will forget what you said, people will forget what you did, but people will never forget how you made them feel.” The Keaton effect is that she made us forget for a few brief moments the madness and chaos of this world and shifted our perspectives of those aspects of ourselves which we previously considered cringe-worthy.  We thought she was beautiful in a quirky way but she confessed to hating her face; she turned body dysmorphia on its head by becoming an accidental style icon when she dared to dress to suit her body and tastes.

With grace and humility, there was no need to topple her from her pedestalbecause she was so reluctant to climb on to it in the first place. Apart from the personal and incomparable legacy of raising het two children whom she courageously adopted in her fifties,  arguably her most memorable legacy to the world may well be the subtle invitation, inspired by her own example, to pursue our own greatness with authenticity. There is no more effective way to detox from pop culture than to star in your own personal story as Diane did in hers.  

RIP Diane Keaton 1946-2025.

Carla Cornelius

Dr Carla seeks to bring a fresh and thought-provoking perspective to today's popular culture. With her Ph.D. in Biblical Counselling, she invites readers to see the relevance of the Bible in addressing the difficult and disturbing issues of our times.